ROCK
STANLEY and EDMOND
Stanley actually took to his confessional to tell us:
“Y’all don’t know, I’m really rock.”
Then he picked leather and fishnets because that’s really rock. And it’s a lot of separates…a skirt, a vest a pair of fishnet tights and a fishnet shirt; Anthony came over to warn Stanley that he promised not to do more than three pieces and he was already up to four.
Last week, for the Red-Carpet Challenge, Edmond said he was known for ruffles and would do ruffles; this week, he claimed to be known for his performance wear. Edmond? You are known for guns and pecs, honey, just do that.
Anyway, he’ll be going for unpolished pants and a rock top, but, you know, sexy. And he’s looking particularly sexy this week in his jeans and pecs-and-guns t-shirt.
Guest Mentor—I guess Anne is still out of town or recovering from the beatings she took mentoring Joshua—is designer Rebecca Minkoff, and she tells Stanley that he’s trying to do a lot, and that he needs to know what to eliminate when he runs out of time. As for Edmond, she tells him to pick a lane and keep his focus.
WHAT STANLEY SAID
I think she possesses this whole rocker chick mentality. It looks a little happy… it could have been darker
WHAT I SAID
Fishnets don’t make it rock, and the top and skirt are too matchy.
WHAT EDMOND SAID
I’m totally loving my look but that doesn’t mean the judges will.
WHAT I SAID
It’s rock’n’sex.
WHAT THE JUDGES SAID
The Beautiful Georgina Chapman™ thought Stanley’s look was contrived, and wasn’t feeling the matching skirt and shirt, and t-shirt and tights. But she loved the ease of Edmond’s look, and the open back; she said it screamed rock’n’roll.
Isaac thought Stanley’s looked like a man’s tie and would have splatted neon yellow paint on it to rock it up; he felt let down this week by Stanley. He called Edmond’s look a “dressy rock star” but loved that the black fabrics; he said it looked like expensive designer wear.
Guest judge, actress and designer, Olivia Culpo thought Stanley’s was too cute and too put together; she said it was like a cheerleader out. She called Edmond’s look fluid and wondered what it might look like without the jacker. Edmond explained that the shirt was sheer, and the model wasn’t wearing a bra. Olivia asked if that was bad, and Alyssa said,
“We can’t do nipples.”
Alyssa said Stanley’s look wasn’t risky enough, but thought it was well-made, to which Isaac said, “How hard is it to glue stripes to leather?” She felt Edmond’s was almost unisex and could work for a male or female rock star
|
Bob, thanks for your recap each week. Watching Project Runway All Stars and reading your critiques are like cereal and milk. They go together. Great job.
ReplyDeleteI echo your observation. I like it when they treat each other with respect and try each week to do their best. Never liked Helen. I love what's left. Anthony is always good for a laugh. He seems like a fun person. I laughed out loud when he said the side biscuits comment. Love Rebecca's input as well. Anne can move on to something else. She comes across as less than pleasant.
When the punk rock band lived here we had two leisure suits from Goodwill. One in bright orange and one in bright blue. Then there was the lead singer in his homecoming queen outfit. So music clothes can be very out there.
ReplyDeletegreat recap! xoxoxox
After so many cringe worthy designs, Edmond finally redeemed himself. Alyssa also redeemed herself from that unflattering oversized outfit she wore last week. She looked stylish and cute last night. The dynamics between Ken and Anthony, not to mention the very funny shade they throw, is going to make it sad to see this season end. The two of them should have their own show.
ReplyDeleteI liked Edmond's the best.
ReplyDelete