CLAIRE AND SHAWN
Oh, you get the sense right away that this will go down in flames ... and I’m pleased by that; indeed. It begins when Shawn, for no reason I can fathom, tells Claire the looks are for fall. I never heard anyone mention fall looks but, Shawn ... I guess she knows best?
Or maybe not, because this week Claire’s facade of twin-love is starting to crack; there is a snappiness and a testiness as she realizes she has to help Shawn before she can work on her own looks. And Shawn’s neediness doesn’t help, given that, at one point, she actually says, “I feel like you are abandoning me.”
And Tim’s critique doesn’t help because he loathes their ideas, and is clearly bothered when Shawn tries to do all the talking, even stopping her at one point to say he’d like to hear from Claire. The twins again whine about working with plus-sized girls—even though it’s Week 7—and Tim shuts that shiz down.
Too bad he couldn’t just shut them both down.
WHAT THEY SAID
Claire—I love that we made outfits that look nothing like anyone else’s on the runway.
Shawn—Liris is working this. She has a pop of color.
WHAT I SAID
Um, Claire, yours look nothing like the others because the others are rather good; I mean, what kind of f**kery is this sleeve belt and frilly one-sleeved mess. As for you, Shawn, a red lip doesn’t constitute a pop of color, and how dare you put Liris in a potato sack—even though she rocked it; again, what kind of f**kery is this?
WHAT THE JUDGES SAID
Zac Posen calls Shawn’s dress trashy, uninspired, and banal; and he says she was just lucky to have had Liris as a model. He calls Claire’s top “bad design” though the jeans, he says, are good, except for the “dumpy butt.” He wonders about the weird tie and Nina says it’s in case you need extra sleeves.
Asia Kate Dillon calls both looks confusing and says many pieces—like the sleeve belt—look like an afterthought.
Nina Garcia asks who would buy these clothes, and Claire tries to say that JCP customers would be inspired by influencers like them—Nina’s head nearly explodes.
Heidi has no idea what these two are doing, and says she’d be sad if she saw people in these clothes.
When she asks who should go Shawn volunteers, and Claire stammers.
|